Tech & Science Viking expert raises doubts over research claiming famous warrior was actually a woman

09:21  13 september  2017
09:21  13 september  2017 Source:   ABC News

Comment: I adore Australian Ninja Warrior. But is it selling us a lie?

  Comment: I adore Australian Ninja Warrior. But is it selling us a lie? I’m a massive fan of Channel Nine’s Australian Ninja Warrior.I’m a massive fan of Channel Nine’s Australian Ninja Warrior.

blog 'joelmayer.blogdetik.com' is not exists.

We are temporarily closed for upgrading our streaming servers. We will back ASAP. Please check back soon. Thanks for your support.

Female Viking warriors. Awesome on TV. Not so great in academic research.© The History Channel Female Viking warriors. Awesome on TV. Not so great in academic research. Doubts have been cast on new research that claimed an ancient Viking warrior buried in Sweden was actually a warrior or a woman.

The story sprang up all over the internet after the research was published in the American Journal of Physical Anthropology.

So were Vikings more progressive than first thought?

Let's break it down.

The original research relied on DNA tests on bones

Researchers conducted tests on a Viking buried in a "well-furnished grave" found in the Swedish town of Birka in the 19th century.

Inside the grave were swords, an axe, a spear, armour-piercing arrows, two shields and two horses.

Australian Ninja Warrior accidentally included a dead stuntman in last night's episode.

  Australian Ninja Warrior accidentally included a dead stuntman in last night's episode. A 28-year-old stuntman who was killed before his attempt at the Australian Ninja Warrior course aired on television was accidentally included on Tuesday night’s leaderboard. In January, Johann Ofner was accidentally shot while filming a video for hip-hop group Bliss n Eso in Brisbane.

blog 'richardcraft.blogdetik.com' is not exists.

blog 'kristinmartin.blogdetik.com' is not exists.

"The complete equipment of a professional warrior," the journal said.

"Furthermore, a full set of gaming pieces indicates knowledge of tactics and strategy stressing the buried individual's role as a high-ranking officer." Researchers said that based on "material and historical" records, it had simply been assumed that the warrior was male.

They ran a DNA test to confirm the sex of the warrior inside the grave, and found a "lack of a Y-chromosome".

"The identification of a female Viking warrior provides a unique insight into the Viking society, social constructions, and exceptions to the norm in the Viking time-period," the journal article read.

"The results call for caution against generalizations regarding social orders in past societies."

The one way Australian Ninja Warrior is different to other versions from around the world.

  The one way Australian Ninja Warrior is different to other versions from around the world. You know those crazy dedicated people you see going for a jog on Christmas Day? They are the kind of people you’ll see competing on Australian Ninja Warrior. You know those crazy dedicated people you see going for a jog on Christmas Day?

While there have been a handful of Viking women found buried with swords before and many researchers doubted that women were ever Viking warriors , this is the first that can truly be identified as both a warrior and a leader, as Hedenstierna-Jonson points out

Error 404: Page Not Found. Jesse Jackson Casts Further Doubt in Chavis Carter Investigation.

So, Vikings were super progressive and allowed boss lady-warriors to run their armies, right?

Maybe not.

A Viking expert has some big issues with the research

Judith Jesch, a Professor of Viking Studies, wrote a comprehensive blog post poking all sorts of holes in the original research.

She noted that:

■ There are doubt about the origins of the bones because they were excavated in the 19th century

■ Her own analysis raises doubts over whether the grave actually belonged to a "high-ranking" officer

■ There were no injuries observed on the skeleton, so there are questions over whether it belonged to a warrior at all

■ Researchers didn't pursue alternative explanations

"These are some of my caveats which I would dearly love people to take into account before tweeting all over the world about women warriors in the Viking Age," Professor Jesch wrote.

She said she believes the "fascination with women warriors" is "is heavily, probably too heavily, influenced by 20th- and 21st-century desires."

Her final thought?

"It's too easy to take the title of an article at face value and send it round the Twittersphere without further thought."

Samuel Johnson's raw interview with Mia Freedman following the death of his sister, Connie. .
Connie Johnson died of cancer just over a week ago , a lot of people have been worrying about her brother Sam. How is he coping? Is he OK? What will he do now that she’s gone?  In the past few years, while Sam and Connie were the public faces of Love Your Sister, Sam has become like Australia’s little brother. Women feel protective of him and never more so than right now in the days after Connie’s death.Of course, Sam isn’t the only one who is grieving.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!