Sport Pitched battles: Countries that face off in the World Cup are more likely to come into real-world conflict

03:07  14 june  2018
03:07  14 june  2018 Source:   abc.net.au

This map shows how much the iPhone 7 costs around the world

  This map shows how much the iPhone 7 costs around the world Two years ago, the newly-unveiled iPhone 7 represented the pinnacle of Apple's smartphone design. Two years ago, the newly-unveiled iPhone 7 represented the pinnacle of Apple's smartphone design.

Could doing battle on the pitch lead to diplomatic or even military conflict ? This five-decade statistical analysis suggests it does.

Does the World Cup make qualifying nations more aggressive?© Provided by ABC News Does the World Cup make qualifying nations more aggressive?

It's World Cup time, and you might expect that such international sporting competitions bring countries together and lower tensions between nations.

But a recent study suggests this is a myth.

Instead, it finds that countries that qualify for the World Cup are more likely to literally do battle with other nations.

And — spoiler alert — if you're a sports fan, you're not going to like the proposed solution.

It all starts with a five-decade analysis of disputes

The study, Nationalism and Conflict: Lessons from International Sports, was released in the journal International Studies Quarterly in late 2017, and was written by Andrew Bertoli, a postdoctoral researcher at Dartmouth University's Dickey Centre for International Understanding.

North Korea reportedly wants a McDonald’s. That could be a pretty big deal.

  North Korea reportedly wants a McDonald’s. That could be a pretty big deal. <p>It is little more than a footnote in the back-and-forth over the planned North Korea summit — but the rumor of a McDonald’s in Pyongyang is juicier than a three-patty Big Mac.</p>North Korean leader Kim Jong Un may allow a “Western hamburger franchise” into the country as a show of goodwill to the United States, according to an intelligence report described by U.S. officials to NBC. That follows remarks by South Korean adviser Chung-in Moon in late April, who said that North Korea might be interested in welcoming a McDonald’s as tensions ease.

1, the remaining countries , constituting most of the world ’s population, will be wondering “What if So which country and whose fans had the more agonizing failed World Cup qualifying campaign? While it was always going to be an uphill battle for Gabon with Morocco and Ivory Coast in its group

Dr Bertoli took data on militarised interstate disputes from the Correlates of War database and fused it with data on countries that qualified and did not qualify for world cups between 1958 and 2010.

To keep the results as close to a randomised trial as possible, Dr Bertoli only used countries that qualified or missed out on qualification by two points or fewer.

Halep fightback keeps French Open hopes alive

  Halep fightback keeps French Open hopes alive Angelique Kerber pushed Simona Halep all the way at Roland Garros, but the world number one remains on course for a first grand slam title.Halep has never won a major but is well placed to earn another shot at improving that record, having lost to Caroline Wozniacki in the Australian Open decider earlier this year.

A match in the 1982 World Cup in Gijón, Spain, is probably the most infamous example of World Cup collusion. Worse, Case 1 would actually be more likely , because banning draws automatically increases the probability of wins and losses.

Related Story. Going To The World Cup With Rooney Sounds Terrible. His face is probably the easiest to meld with a root vegetable too. 3. Dele Alli. He’s also the most likely to do a Phil Neville and steam through the back of some unsuspecting Columbian playmaker, upon which his frozen

The results are surprising. Here are six charts that show the links between qualifying for the World Cup and being more aggressive on the world stage.

1. Countries that qualified started more disputes after qualification

In the four years before a World Cup, the number of disputes initiated by countries that qualified and did not qualify are not far apart.

But after qualifying for the cup, there is a large and noticeable spike in the number of disputes initiated by the qualifiers.

This peaks in the second year after the cup, when the qualifiers initiate almost three times the number of disputes of the non-qualifiers.

Could the World Cup actually be causing these countries to be so much more aggressive?

The answer, Dr Bertoli theorises, lies in the tournament's effect on nationalism:

"… most scholars agree that international sporting events increase [nationalism].

Trump calls for Russia to be reinstated to G-7, threatens allies on trade

  Trump calls for Russia to be reinstated to G-7, threatens allies on trade Russia was ousted from the group of nations after its 2014 annexation of Crimea. “Now, I love our country. I have been Russia’s worst nightmare. . . . But with that being said, Russia should be in this meeting,” Trump said Friday as he left the White House. “It may not be politically correct, but we have a world to run. . . . They should let Russia back in.”Trump’s comments, made just hours before arriving in Canada for the annual G-7 summit, have the potential to further upend talks with other leaders who were already fuming about the U.S. leader’s protectionist trade policies.U.S.

What matters more is how Russia responds off the field: Can it prove to itself that it is the nation Mr. Putin preaches that it is ? Can it deliver a spectacle — even in the face of reinforced sanctions Mexico Wages a Psychological Battle Against Its World Cup Demons. June 6, 2018. Image.

France and Croatia will face off in the World Cup final on Sunday afternoon. Didier Deschamps' men are favourites heading into the final in Moscow. 'I could not be more excited about this challenge': Digne raring to go at Everton after completing £18m move from Barcelona Five-year deal.

"Many studies show that international sports tend to make the national discourses within countries more hawkish.

"Reporters often describe games in military terminology and compare wins and losses to past battles."

The graph above shows that any effect of qualifying on initiating disputes seems to dissipate by the time the qualifiers for the next world cup roll around, three and a half years after the tournament.

2. By two years, qualifiers initiated two and a half times more disputes

Two years after qualification, the countries in the sample that qualified for the World Cup initiated 49 disputes, compared with 19 initiated by the non-qualifiers.

The Soviet Union is a big contributor to the qualifying tally, initiating 12 unique disputes in the two years after qualifying. Most of these followed the 1958 World Cup, at the height of the Cold War, and were initiated against a diverse array of countries, including Iran, Japan, Taiwan, and of course, the United States.

Nigeria also initiated three disputes against its neighbours, Chad and Liberia, following appearances in the 1994 and 1998 tournaments.

Neymar scores stunning goal as Brazil beat feisty Austria 3-0

  Neymar scores stunning goal as Brazil beat feisty Austria 3-0 Brazil scored three superbly-taken goals to beat feisty Austria 3-0 in sweltering conditions on Sunday to put the finishing touches to their impressive World Cup preparations. Gabriel Jesus put Brazil ahead in the 36th minute with a delightful dinked finish past Heinz Lindner before Neymar, starting a game for the first time since his injury in February, added a stunning second goal in the 63rd minute.Neymar left Aleksander Dragovic on the floor with a dragback and then scored with a shot between Lindner's legs.

But a new study, which finds that nations who have played in the World Cup soccer are more likely to get involved in international conflict , is calling that notion into question.

World Cup 2018 Group G table. Belgium are group winners. Katie Price's sex tape snub as porn barons say she'd make more cash selling cats. PITCHED BATTLE . Locals slam German towel tactics of tourists who marked off beach with TENTS.

And France initiated six disputes after qualifying for the 1958, 1978 and 1982 world cups. Three of these were initiated against former colony Tunisia.

By contrast, the French initiated only three disputes after not qualifying for the 1962 and 1994 tournaments.

3. Countries that qualified initiated a third more disputes after qualification than before

Further analysis of those who qualified reveals more about the effects of the World Cup on interstate aggression.

In the two years before qualification, the qualifiers initiated 36 disputes between them. They initiated another 49 in the two years after qualifying.

The Soviet Union initiated eight disputes against other nations in the two years before qualifying for the World Cup. Seven of these occurred after the 1958 tournament, during the Cold War.

This is a third less than the aforementioned 12 disputes it started after qualifying in various years.

Argentina initiated a single dispute against neighbouring Chile before the 1958 tournament.

It initiated two more disputes after qualifying for the cup, as well as initiating one further against the United Kingdom after qualifying in 1974.

And Cameroon, which initiated no disputes before qualifying, initiated three disputes against neighbouring Nigeria after the 1994 tournament.

FIFA overhauls world ranking system

  FIFA overhauls world ranking system FIFA will attempt to combat "manipulation" of its world ranking system by introducing an overhauled points formula following the World Cup. The change was approved at a FIFA Council Meeting on Sunday in a bid for the standings to better reflect the true strength of each national team.The present method, which has been in place since 2006, has received criticism for enabling countries to boost their position by scheduling low-risk friendlies against weaker opposition, therefore receiving favourable seedings at major tournaments.

Nothing can turn them away from the pitch . When Fifa announced it was handing the World Cup Sashy Nathan, the legal researcher who compiled the report, said the hardest questions are likely to come from European teams. “Somehow Russia got the World Cup and we have to get on with it.

Two years ago, Iceland reached the quarterfinals of the European Championship by defeating England, a country with more than 150 times as many people. Iceland faces an uphill battle in Russia. How Russia Beat Saudi Arabia in the World Cup Opener.

"The fact that this increase begins after qualification accords with historical evidence showing that many countries experience a surge of nationalism when they qualify for the World Cup," Dr Bertoli writes.

By contrast, the number of disputes initiated by non-qualifiers fell from 33 before to 19 after not qualifying.

4. Not only do the qualifiers start more disputes, the disputes they start are more aggressive

The COW database codes each dispute initiated by its highest level of aggressive act. The scale of these acts begins at one (a threat to use force) and increases in aggression up to 20 (beginning an interstate war).

In the two years after the world cup, the median highest act for the qualifiers was 15 ("seizure") while the median highest act for non-qualifiers was 11 ("fortifying the border").

The highest hostile act that occurs in this dataset is 17, which is a "clash".

The three disputes Cameroon initiated against Nigeria were at this level, and involved an oil-rich disputed area in the Bakassi peninsula region. In one of these attacks Cameroon attacked and captured a Nigerian post, only to later lose it in a counter-offensive.

5. Military participation rises in qualifying countries

Before each world cup, there is little difference in the average military participation rate between qualifiers (0.847 per cent) and non-qualifiers (0.821 per cent).

But after qualifications, the average rate jumps to 0.910 per cent for the qualifiers, while dropping slightly to 0.815 per cent for non-qualifiers.

Third time lucky? Michael Turnbull 'will begin filming Netflix dating show Game Of Love in America' after appearing on The Bachelorette and Bachelor In Paradise

  Third time lucky? Michael Turnbull 'will begin filming Netflix dating show Game Of Love in America' after appearing on The Bachelorette and Bachelor In Paradise Will it be 'third time lucky' for Michael Turnbull?After failing to find love on The Bachelorette and Bachelor In Paradise, the 37-year-old heartthrob looks set to appear on another dating program.

But while the Seleção will be keen to get one over on the team they beat to win their last final, in 2002, more significant battles lie ahead, with Dani Alves and Marcelo among those likely to be playing in their last World Cup .

With the World Cup kicking off in less than a month and tensions with the west at their worst level in decades, Observer writers and Russia experts go behind Anyone who challenges it faces a threat of violence’. It is the most politically charged World Cup in recent memory: Russia, resurgent under

In fact, the average increase for qualifiers is 0.044 percentage points, which is around three times higher than the non-qualifiers at 0.016 percentage points.

6. Countries who play against each other in the World Cup are more likely to end up in disputes with each other

Expanding the sample to include all tournaments back to the 1930s, in the years before the World Cup, countries who would play each other got into nine disputes between themselves.

In the years after, countries who played each other at the World Cup got into 21 disputes.

Italy and France, for example, had only one dispute between them in the years before the 1938 cup, but afterwards, they got into three, although they ostensibly were related to World War II.

Canada and France experienced no disputes between them in the years leading up to the 1986 cup, but got into two disputes in the years after their match.

And South Korea and Spain, being on opposite sides of the globe, would usually have very little to do with each other, but after their World Cup match in 2002, Spain seized a South Korean weapons shipment which was en route to Senegal, claiming it was illegal.

But wait a minute … I haven't seen Australia on any of these maps!

Very astute you are — that's because Australia did not meet the criteria of qualifying or not qualifying by fewer than two points, to be included in the sample in any of the world cups between 1958 and 2010.

We can still investigate what happened here as a result of our qualifications, though the results would look pretty underwhelming on a graph.

Between 1958 and 2010, Australia qualified for the cup in 1972, 2006 and 2010 (an underwhelming result by the standards of world football).

In the years before and after qualifying for these tournaments, Australia initiated a total of zero disputes (although the COW MID dispute series ends in the middle of 2010, and there may have been disputes initiated by Australia beyond that date).

Federer battles hard for semi-final spot in Halle

  Federer battles hard for semi-final spot in Halle World number one Roger Federer was tested once again in Halle but did enough to overpower Australian Matthew Ebden 7-6(2) 7-5 in the quarter-finals on Friday. Nine-time Halle champion Federer, who saved two match points to beat Benoit Paire in the second round, edged a tense opening set against 60th ranked Ebden in the tiebreak with a backhand winner.Ebden was leading 5-3 in the second set against the 36-year-old before the Swiss fought back to secure four consecutive games to set-up a semi-final against American Denis Kudla.

SAMBA STYLE New Brazil kit leaked ahead of 2018 World Cup . President Gianni Infantino wants all 211 member countries to vote to decide on the hosts. Katie Price's sex tape snub as porn barons say she'd make more cash selling cats. Shopped to cops. Hero Waitrose driver 'slammed into

So that means we were pretty unaggressive to begin with, and qualifying for the tournament did little to change that.

In fact, as Dr Bertoli writes: "Countries where soccer is not the most popular sport experienced no change in aggression from the World Cup. These countries include the United States, Japan, New Zealand, Ireland, Australia, the United Arab Emirates, Jamaica, and Trinidad."

But history shows that Australia is not immune from tensions arising out of international sport, as evidenced by the infamous Bodyline cricket series of 1932-33.

Bodyline involved the deliberate tactic on the part of the English cricket team of bowling fast, short balls directly at a batsman in order to deliberately intimidate him.

In an era when helmets were not used, the tactic caused injuries to multiple Australian players.

This resulted in some terse cables between the cricket boards of both countries, nearly sparking a diplomatic incident that was only calmed when prime minister Joseph Lyons convinced the Australians to back down in the interests of avoiding the economic consequences of a British boycott of Australian goods.

So, what's the solution?

Dr Bertoli suggests that sporting events could be created where teams compete as small regional blocks.

This, he says, would make neighbouring states allies rather than adversaries.

He continues: "While this format could increase animosity between the competing regional blocks, practitioners could minimise any negative political fallout by refraining from pitting neighbouring regions against each other."

So perhaps Australia might join up with New Zealand in pursuit of sporting glory? Hmm, maybe not.

If you're unhappy with that idea, Dr Bertoli proposes preventing avoidable games between countries with underlying political tensions.

He suggests opposing bids to hold major sporting events in "countries where leaders show a penchant for using nationalist sentiment to increase support for aggressive foreign policies".

"For example, allowing Putin to host the 2014 Winter Olympics and 2018 World Cup was a poor decision; international sports organisations should not make similar mistakes in the future."

Food for thought when you're watching Australia take on the world this World Cup.

In Pictures: Socceroos 2018 FIFA World Cup Squad

KAZAN, RUSSIA - JUNE 12:  The Australia players pose for a team photo during an Australia Socceroos media opportunity ahead of the FIFA World Cup 2018 at Stadium Trudovye Rezervy on June 12, 2018 in Kazan, Russia.  (Photo by Robert Cianflone/Getty Images) Socceroos 2018 FIFA World Cup Squad

Federer battles hard for semi-final spot in Halle .
World number one Roger Federer was tested once again in Halle but did enough to overpower Australian Matthew Ebden 7-6(2) 7-5 in the quarter-finals on Friday. Nine-time Halle champion Federer, who saved two match points to beat Benoit Paire in the second round, edged a tense opening set against 60th ranked Ebden in the tiebreak with a backhand winner.Ebden was leading 5-3 in the second set against the 36-year-old before the Swiss fought back to secure four consecutive games to set-up a semi-final against American Denis Kudla.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!