Sport AFL ump touch confusion after Blues fined

00:32  16 may  2018
00:32  16 may  2018 Source:   msn.com

Sydney Zoo keeps name after legal stoush

  Sydney Zoo keeps name after legal stoush Taronga Zoo and Sydney Zoo Pty Ltd have resolved a legal battle over the use of the name Sydney Zoo with the new zoo to open in western Sydney in early 2019. A zoo under construction in western Sydney has won the right to be named Sydney Zoo after a legal battle with the city's famous Taronga Zoo. An agreement was reached by the two organisations out of court after Taronga Zoo launched legal action against Sydney Zoo Pty Ltd in the Federal Court earlier this year.

The AFL tribunal has fined Carlton's Ed and Charlie Curnow a week after Geelong's Tom Hawkins was banned for the same offence.

THE AFL has admitted it has revamped the way it judges umpire contact cases after letting Richmond superstar Dustin Martin off with a contentious fine . The Martin ruling has caused widespread confusion because Geelong's Tom Hawkins and Carlton's Ed Curnow both received one-match bans

Steven Hocking© Scott Barbour/AFL Media/Getty Images Steven Hocking Tom Hawkins might be feeling a little hard done by after Carlton's Curnow brothers were let off with a fine, but that feeling might be short-lived.

AFL football boss Steve Hocking still has the option to appeal after Charlie and Ed Curnow were fined rather than suspended after being sent directly to the tribunal for making intentional contact with an umpire.

Their verdicts mirrored that of Gold Coast co-captain Steven May on Monday night.

All three were charged with intentional contact with a whistleblower and successfully argued the charge down to careless contact and a $1000 fine.

Hurricanes march on with win over Blues

  Hurricanes march on with win over Blues <p>The Hurricanes have pulled clear in the second half to beat the Blues 36-15 and make it nine Super Rugby wins on the trot.</p>Cross-code star Williams returned from a lengthy injury layoff to set up a try with a trademark offload but was otherwise subdued for the home side, who fell away in the second half at Eden Park on Friday.

AFL ump touch confusion after Blues fined . The AFL tribunal has fined Carlton's Ed and Charlie Curnow a week after Geelong's Tom Hawkins was banned for the same

A hot-tempered argument made no progress in her bid to overturn the decision as the sixth seeded Czech went on to lose the game on unfortunate circumstances. AFL ump touch confusion after Blues fined .

The bar for intentionally touching an umpire appeared to have been set at a one-game ban a week earlier at the tribunal when Hawkins was rubbed out for the same offence.

Unlike the three players who followed him, the Geelong spearhead took a one-game ban in a plea bargain-style deal after he was threatened with a two-match suspension for touching an umpire during the Cats' round seven win over GWS.

He's probably wishing he had rolled the dice after what transpired at AFL House on Monday and Tuesday night.

AFL will appeal against tribunal decision to clear Carlton's Charlie and Ed Curnow over umpire contact

  AFL will appeal against tribunal decision to clear Carlton's Charlie and Ed Curnow over umpire contact The AFL will appeal against the controversial decision by the tribunal to clear two Carlton players of making intentional contact with an umpire. The decision follows a fortnight of debate over the rules regarding contact with on-field officials.On Tuesday night, both Charlie and Ed Curnow of the Blues were found not guilty of intentional contact with an umpire but guilty of the lesser charge of making careless contact.Each were fined $1,000 but will be available to play against Melbourne on Sunday.

THE AFL has admitted it has revamped the way it judges umpire contact cases after letting Richmond superstar Dustin Martin off with a contentious fine . The Martin ruling has caused widespread confusion because Geelong's Tom Hawkins and Carlton's Ed Curnow both received one-match bans

Just hours before May successfully dodged a ban on Monday evening, AFL match review officer Michael Christian made his position on umpire contact clear.

"We have got to be really vigilant, especially in stop-play situations," Christian said.

"I think the message is clear that you cannot make contact with umpires."

After Hawkins appeared to cop his right whack for a momentary brain fade, the tribunal's decisions to let off May and the Blues brothers have blurred the line again.

Interestingly enough, Carlton football chief Andrew McKay sat in on May's hearing the day before his players faced the music.

The Curnow boys made almost identical cases to the tribunal.

Charlie touched umpire Matt Stevic and Ed umpire Nathan Williamson during Carlton's drought-breaking win over Essendon at the MCG on Sunday.

In similar statements submitted into evidence, both umpires said they didn't say anything at the time contact was made, neither felt threatened or had any issues with what had occurred.

Fittler's unexpected reaction to Smith retirement

  Fittler's unexpected reaction to Smith retirement NSW coach Brad Fittler revealed his initial thoughts about Cameron Smith's retirement from representative football. Smith announced his immediate retirement from representative football, bringing down the curtain on a glittering career that included 56 Tests and 42 State of Origin games.Oddly enough, Fittler was in Melbourne to discuss his Origin plans with Storm coach Craig Bellamy when he found out about Smith’s retirement.The Blues coach spotted Maroons coach Kevin Walters at Storm training but still was oblivious to Smith’s decision to call time.

Both hearings took less than 30 minutes, the jury of Stewart Loewe, Jason Johnson and Wayne Henwood taking four and 12 minutes respectively to come to their conclusions.

"I'd just like to say that we both highly respect umpires and their position in the game as officiators and their importance to the game at all levels," Ed Curnow said as he left the hearing.

"We both understand the tribunal's decision and we respect the process involved."

The pair are free to play Melbourne at the MCG on Sunday following the verdict.

North Melbourne skipper Jack Ziebell was cleared of a kneeing charge in Tuesday night's other case.

The AFL match review officer offered Ziebell a one-game ban for kneeing Richmond's Reece Conca in the first quarter of the Tigers' hard-fought 10-point at Etihad Stadium on Sunday.

The jury found the impact wasn't enough to warrant a report after deliberating for less than five minutes.

NRL legend backs selection of veteran Blue .
Boyd Cordner's scratchy form for the Sydney Roosters has left some questioning his selection, but a former Blues great has come to his defence.Both Cordner and Klemmer have shown less than stellar form for their respective sides this season, but Harragon said that talk about the two Origin veterans not being selected is “totally incorrect”.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!