Sport Comment: Melbourne Victory's A-League grand final win not tarnished by VAR controversy

06:56  07 may  2018
06:56  07 may  2018 Source:   msn.com

Victory could add to coaching sanctions

  Victory could add to coaching sanctions Melbourne Victory's board will meet to consider a club sanction on coaches Jean-Paul de Marigny and Dean Anastasiadis in the wake of their A-League bans.De Marigny, Kevin Muscat's assistant, and Anastasiadis, the goalkeeping coach, leapt from the bench in the wake of Terry Antonis's extra-time winner in Saturday night's semi-final against Sydney FC.

Comments Off on Melbourne Victory ’ s A - League grand final win not First let’s get one thing straight. Melbourne Victory ’ s A - League grand final win is neither tarnished nor The A - League grand final VAR meltdown is, of course, a step beyond the usual review system controversy .

Melbourne Victory ' s A - League grand final win is neither tarnished nor compromised by the technical glitch that rendered the Video Assistant Referee system as useless as a linesman with an invisible flag, writes Richard Hinds.

Kevin Muscat holds the championship trophy after their grand final victory.© AAP Image/Dan Himbrechts Kevin Muscat holds the championship trophy after their grand final victory. First let's get one thing straight.

Melbourne Victory's A-League grand final win is neither tarnished nor compromised by the technical glitch that, at the most vital moment, rendered the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) system as useless as a linesman with an invisible flag.

As Victory fans are entitled to remind us, referees were perfectly capable of making incorrect game-defining decisions by themselves before technology was imposed upon them.

Thus countless trophies have been won and lost in games where human errors rather than computer malfunctions led to a goal being wrongly awarded or overruled.

Hardaker banned for 14 months over failed drugs test

  Hardaker banned for 14 months over failed drugs test Former Castleford Tigers fullback Zak Hardaker has been handed a 14-month suspension after he failed a drugs test leading up to the 2017 Super League Grand Final, the Rugby Football League said on Monday. The 26-year-old was suspended by Castleford having failed the test after a Super 8s game on Sept. 8 before being sacked in February. Hardaker also missed out on the chance to represent England in the 2017 rugby league World Cup.

During Australia’ s A League grand final , technical issues prevented the video assistant referee ( VAR ) from reviewing a debatable winning goal by Melbourne Victory .

VAR controversy in A - League Grand final as clear offside goal wins title for Melbourne Victory . VAR controversy overshadowed Melbourne Victory ’ s win over

In this case what the FFA acknowledged was a "technical failure in the VAR system" meant the referee and his assistant's mistake in neglecting to call offside was not detected until it was too late to make amends.

So a human error was made, as has been the case since they put the pea in whistles, and the machine was unavailable to correct it.

Yet, inevitably, disgruntled Jets fans feel cheated by VAR alone because the imposition of refereeing technology has created the myth of decision-making infallibility.

This is not to excuse the breakdown of the VAR technology, which seemed symbolic of a cursed A-League season. (Let's face it, had Perth Glory signed Lionel Messi he would have suffered a season ending injury walking onto the pitch for the first game).

A-League grand final Lowdown: Newcastle Jets v Melbourne Victory

  A-League grand final Lowdown: Newcastle Jets v Melbourne Victory Players to watch, likely teams, key battles and the men in the dug-out for Saturday's A-League grand finalSaturday 7:50pm, McDonald Jones Stadium, Newcastle.

VAR controversy overshadowed Melbourne Victory ’ s win over Newcastle Jets in the A - League Grand Final . The Football Federation of Australia (FFA) has admitted the vision feed supplied to the VAR crashed 30 seconds before Victory ’ s early goal that clearly should have been ruled out for offside.

VAR controversy overshadowed Melbourne Victory ’ s win over Newcastle Jets in the A - League Grand Final . The Football Federation of Australia (FFA) has admitted the vision feed supplied to the VAR crashed 30 seconds before Victory ’ s early goal that clearly should have been ruled out for offside.

It was completely unacceptable that a few minutes after the VAR capture software failed to display evidence three Victory players were offside, television viewers could see for themselves — over and over — that the goal should have been denied.

But these useless — for Jets fans, infuriating — VAR images did not just condemn the failed machinery. They explained why sport is now either captive to, or enhanced by, replay technology depending on your view.

Those who call for the abolition of the various review systems after a dodgy LBW or a borderline NRL Bunker decision — and now the horrendous VAR meltdown — conveniently forget that television replays were once used to second guess and denigrate on-field officials.

Had there been no VAR, functioning or otherwise, a slightly less conclusive replay of the Victory players standing offside would have been shown over and over, and the Jets fans would have been just as outraged.

Victory beat Jets to win A-League title

  Victory beat Jets to win A-League title <p>The Jets' brave grand-final performance wasn't enough to stop Melbourne Victory claiming the 2017-18 A-League championship.</p>Melbourne Victory have snuffed out Newcastle's A-League fairytale at the final hurdle, defeating the Jets 1-0 to win a record fourth A-League title.

Immense courage from goalkeeper Lawrence Thomas helped Melbourne Victory win their fourth A - League grand final .

VAR controversy overshadowed Melbourne Victory ’ s win over Newcastle Jets in the A - League Grand Final . The Football Federation of Australia (FFA) has admitted the vision feed supplied to the VAR crashed 30 seconds before Victory ’ s early goal that clearly should have been ruled out for offside.

In this case, however, their anger would be with the referee and not the box of wires and circuits that might have cost them the championship.

In the face of this bombardment we relented to replays that told us what was perfectly obvious — officials seeing things in real time from sometimes awkward angles and with a split second to decide sometimes make mistakes.

Technology just as flawed as the humans who use it

What we have failed to understand, or acknowledge, is that decision-making machinery is only as good as the sometimes misfiring software and error-prone humans who use it.

Just ask the Sydney Swans fans, who were the left bemused by the AFL's ludicrously inexact score review system on Saturday night when North Melbourne was awarded a goal that appeared to have been touched.

That Sydney lost the game by less than a goal only made the decision more galling, the minor consolation being that, unlike the Victory goal, this one was analysed by the official review system.

The NRL Bunker is subject to reflexive condemnation, most recently after the controversial try awarded last week - incorrectly, the NRL conceded - to St George-Illawarra's Nene Macdonald in a tight win over the Roosters.

A-L champ Berisha hints at move abroad

  A-L champ Berisha hints at move abroad Melbourne Victory star Besart Berisha says there is nothing left for him to win in the A-League after claiming his fourth grand final win.The 32-year-old didn't manage a shot on goal in Saturday night's 1-0 grand final win over the Newcastle Jets at McDonald Jones Stadium.

Melbourne Victory celebrate their A - League grand final triumph. Photograph: Dan Himbrechts/AAP. Lawrence Thomas bravery helps Melbourne Victory win dramatic A - League grand final .

The 2018 A - League Grand Final was the thirteenth A - League Grand Final , played on 5 May 2018. The match took place at McDonald Jones Stadium, with Newcastle Jets hosting Melbourne Victory

As much as the decision making itself, the spectacle of NRL Bunker officials scanning video to see if they can make the correct call only emphasises the fallibility of the process. Yet this human element is ignored by the serial malcontents who mistakenly equate technology with 100 per cent accuracy.

The A-League grand final VAR meltdown is, of course, a step beyond the usual review system controversy.

If technology is employed we should reasonably expect that it is plugged in and working, regardless of the decisions it spits out.

Especially so if you believe that officials have become more hesitant to make close calls knowing they can rely on technology to correct their non-decisions.

As you wonder if a cricket umpire was hesitant to give a batsman out knowing the fielding team can review, you might also wonder if the referees in the A-League grand final would have blown offside if they did not mistakenly believe the VAR would cover their tracks.

Again, however, this only exposes the naive belief that technology is capable of accurately assessing every close call rather than merely improving the percentage of correct decisions, which it has done in most sports where it is employed.

Modern sport prides itself on being on the cutting edge of scientific technology. Yet, in its reliance on decision-making technology, it appears to be in the thrall of science fiction and that perennial storyline where machines replace humans.

As dejected Jets fans can tell you, a machine's ability to provide its game-defining data at the right moment is as vital, and as fallible, as the data it provides.

VAR concerns grow louder for World Cup .
There are concerns about the use of the recently-approved VAR for the World Cup after the technology failed during the A-league grand final on Saturday night.Melbourne Victory beat Newcastle Jets 1-0 in the season decider at McDonald Jones Stadium on Saturday night with Kosta Barbarouses’ goal in the ninth minute the only difference between the two sides.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!