Sport Score review system still yet to prove its worth in AFL

01:12  10 april  2018
01:12  10 april  2018 Source:

Suspected broken leg for Collingwood's Tim Broomhead after he kicks post

  Suspected broken leg for Collingwood's Tim Broomhead after he kicks post Young Collingwood forward Tim Broomhead suffered a shocking injury at the MCG when he kicked the goalpost while trying to score a goal. Collingwood forward Tim Broomhead looks to have suffered a broken leg after kicking the goal post at the MCG on Saturday when he was trying to score a goal.The incident occurred at the 13-minute mark of the first quarter when the 24-year-old chased the football as it rolled towards goal and tried to kick it across the line.WARNING: Graphic visionTom Phillips managed to roll through the Pies' second goal, but Tim Broomhead has been stretchered off after a suspected broken leg.

The AFL should get rid of its score review system now before it does any more damage to the game it ' s suppose to be improving. And the League needs to go further and lay down the law to broadcasters and journalists over what they can and can’t say in regards to umpiring decisions.

AFL football boss Steve Hocking admits improvements must be made to the score review system labelled But Hardwick, who has been a strident critic of the score review system , was still fuming about the decision after the game. 'Greed at its finest': Cibulkova slammed for 'awful sportsmanship'.

a woman standing in front of a crowd© Sporting News The introduction of video technology into sports adjudication has been a vexed issue for quite a while now.

Few people would argue the toss about the philosophy behind it, making as sure as possible that the correct decisions are made. It’s the implementation and execution that causes all the headaches.

Well, for some sports. Tennis, for example, a pioneer in the field, seems to have no such issues with its Hawk-Eye, almost certainly because a ball hitting a line or not is a pretty simple black and white call, quickly requested and judged.

But there’s few, if any other sports, which haven’t had their problems with it. Cricket’s DRS, for example, is now not just a method of ruling on stumpings and run outs, but LBWs, catches, no-balls, even boundaries.

Did the NRL get it right? Questions linger over Manly cap scandal

  Did the NRL get it right? Questions linger over Manly cap scandal These are the questions the NRL has to answer over its handling of the Manly salary cap scandal.The NRL’s investigation of Manly's salary cap rorting has raised more questions than it has provided answers.

The AFL 's score review system is under fresh scrutiny, with Richmond coach Damien Hardwick labelling it "an embarrassment" to the game. "I sit here and I still don't know how it got turned over," he said.

Still - Yet - Already. English Grammar Rules. Yet is occasionally used in affirmative sentences, giving the sentences a similar meaning as the use of still . Note that this is more formal and not common.

And decisions on its use for captains or batsmen are virtually strategies to go with bowling rotations, field placements and declarations.

Football codes, meanwhile, have presented on-going challenges. In rugby league, the video referee is now as much a part of each game as the full-back or front-rower. Domestically, the A-League’s trial of the VAR appears to have created more problems than it has solved. And nor is the AFL immune.

Score reviews in the AFL might still occupy a small percentage of decisions made during a game of near two hours’ duration. But they continue to cause more than their share of grief. And round three hardly provided a ringing endorsement for their upside.

Bitcoin Is Still Way Over-Valued, Researchers Find

  Bitcoin Is Still Way Over-Valued, Researchers Find Given Bitcoin’s meteoric rise in 2017, and persistent slump this year, it’s easy to wonder just how much the digital currency is really worth. Given Bitcoin’s meteoric rise in 2017, and persistent slump this year, it’s easy to wonder just how much the digital currency is really worth.

The AFL 's score review system has copped an absolute flacking on Sunday afternoon after making a terrible error. During the Richmond Tigers' clash against Hawthorn at the MCG, a decision had to be sent upstairs twice because of an initial incorrect verdict.

Prosper, for its part, has raised the average credit score of its borrowers by 10 points since the turn of the year — a reflection, it says, of its “continued increase in loss-conservatism”. But buyers, rather than sellers, still have the whip hand, says Matt Burton, chief executive of Orchard.

At Etihad Stadium on Saturday night, Adelaide’s Richard Douglas appeared to have kicked a goal despite a desperate St Kilda smother, endorsed by a goal umpire who wanted to check whether there in fact had been a faint touch.

A long delay and countless replays for the men in the video box ensued, none seemingly any clearer than the last. Surely that meant the decision remained a goal? Nope. The video folks had obviously spotted something no one else had been able to see.

Coincidentally, at almost the same moment in the Sydney-GWS game at the SCG, a similar incident took place. This time, the process was quick, clean and efficient, and given the inconclusiveness of the vision, the on-field official’s original call enshrined.

But that was a rare tick on a bad weekend for the score review. Because on Sunday in Melbourne and Perth came two complete howlers.

At the MCG in the Richmond-Hawthorn game, Tiger forward Jason Castagna and Hawk defender Jack Gunston jostled to get to a ball heading across the Richmond goal line first.

Jets happy to face desperate Glory in AL

  Jets happy to face desperate Glory in AL The prospect of facing a Perth side fighting for their A-League season is something out-of-form Newcastle should relish, according to coach Ernie Merrick. Playing a desperate Perth Glory is the perfect A-League finals preparation for the high-flying but suddenly out-of-form Newcastle Jets, according to their coach Ernie Merrick.After thrilling A-League fans for most of the season with their attacking approach, second-placed Newcastle have stumbled over the past couple of rounds. They were thrashed 5-2 at Adelaide and last Sunday lost 3-0 at home to Melbourne City, failing to score for the first time this season.

Even the Hawks, who have dominated the modern football landscape and are sitting in fourth position, are trying to prove that they are still good and relevant and haven’t evaporated into thin air after many critics predicted their And don’t write off the Saints, Lions or Blues just yet . Welcome to AFL in 2018.

That could prove to be an increasingly big problem, because ESA claimants are making up a bigger proportion of the caseload The result is that not one Work Programme provider met their minimum contractual requirements, yet still received tax payer handouts for failure, also a large % of the job

Gunston clearly got there, Castagna not. But the score review incredibly confirmed a Richmond goal. That was until the vociferous protests of an army of Hawks caused the field umpire to call for a review of the review.

Eventually, justice prevailed, seemingly the only explanation that the video team, having watched regular forward Gunston in action, had momentarily got their ends mixed up and thought he’d kicked a goal for his own side.

Then, in the final game of the round at Optus Stadium, West Coast’s Chris Masten marked in the goal square and played on, Geelong defender Tom Stewart desperately trying to get a hand to the ball as he kicked.

The goal umpire called a goal, but wanted to double check. The only relevant replay showed clearly that Stewart’s hand and arm came over the top of Masten’s foot, but that the Eagle had got a clear boot to ball. Incredibly, the goal umpire’s call was overturned.

You could write all this off as a bad couple of days, but for the fact the anomalies and inconsistencies just keep cropping up.

And keep cropping up a good decade after Geelong’s Tom Hawkins goal in the nail-biting 2009 grand final (which replays showed had actually shaved a post) began the discussion about introducing score reviews.

Phil Gould livid with 'ridiculous' two-week ban handed down to South Sydney's Sam Burgess

  Phil Gould livid with 'ridiculous' two-week ban handed down to South Sydney's Sam Burgess The two-game suspension handed down to South Sydney enforcer Sam Burgess hasn’t been well received by outspoken Channel Nine commentator Phil Gould. Burgess was found guilty of dangerous contact on Canterbury’s Josh Morris at the NRL judiciary on Tuesday night and ousted for a fortnight of action.The 29-year-old was in possession of the ball at the time of the incident in the second half of the Good Friday clash, with Morris having difficulty swallowing after Burgess’s elbow made contact with his throat.

Data and statistics are reinventing the ways in which AFL teams win games. In this explainer, Hawthorn FC Data Consultant Darren O’Shaughnessy walks us through Expected Score , a statistical model providing new insights into success on the field.

Not a Global Citizen yet ? Dalits, also known as ‘untouchables’ who were considered to be outside of the caste system , suffered particularly badly under this system - stories abound of ‘untouchable’ children being spat on and forced to bathe in the same water as animals.

It was two-and-a-half years later, for the 2012 season, that the AFL finally took the plunge. But despite that lead-up time, the system had plenty of holes. That might have been understandable. That those problems continue to occur six years later isn’t.

We still don’t have the same access to the same amount of replays at every venue, the extent of coverage dependent on the broadcaster. We still don’t have consistency in either when reviews are called, or in how they’re ruled upon by the officials upstairs.

And like other sports, we routinely exceed the original brief, shots which may or may not have been touched off the mark 30-40 metres from goal also regularly reviewed despite the near-impossibility of an accurate call.

In the first weekend of the season, the score review was used effectively to judge whether a Port Adelaide player had taken a mark or not on the line between the goal and point post. The decision was a legitimate mark, but in the meantime, he’d lost his opportunity to play on and reduce the angle to goal.

As for the necessity for the video evidence to be conclusive to overturn an original decision, wasn’t the number of replays waded through to arrive at a decision on Douglas’s goal on Saturday night enough of a statement in itself that the evidence was in no way conclusive?

The AFL football operations department has plenty on its plate. But the whole video review system needs to be a much higher priority than it appears to be.

That Hawkins goal nearly 10 years ago was as close as we’ve come to the line about “what if it costs a team a premiership” actually occurring. Surely that’s been more than enough time not just to institute the checks and balances to make sure there’s not a repeat, but to make sure they actually work properly?

*You can read all RoCo’s work at Footyology.

No Genia, no worries for Rebels: Hodge .
Melbourne's Reece Hodge says it's important for the confidence of his Super Rugby side to prove they can win without their injured star halfback Will Genia. Rebels and Wallabies utility back Reece Hodge, who missed the Jaguares' loss with a hamstring injury, said it would be a big confidence boost for the team to prove they could win without Genia.Michael Ruru will start at halfback while Australia under 20s halfback Harrison Goddard, who made his Super Rugby debut for the Rebels last season, will be on the bench.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!