Money 'Can't legislate against stupidity', franchise inquiry told

23:31  10 june  2018
23:31  10 june  2018 Source:   smh.com.au

Origin Energy offer power bill relief

  Origin Energy offer power bill relief Energy Minister says price cuts 'a step in the right direction'Electricity prices in Queensland and South Australia will be slashed and Origin Energy said this morning it would also freeze tariffs in New South Wales and the ACT.

Mr Sutherland said government could not legislate to protect people from their own “ stupidity ” or conduct when they signed up to become franchisees . The inquiry is probing whether the existing code stands up against allegations of unconscionable and deceptive behaviour by franchise groups.

The government cannot stop small business owners from making stupid decisions, a leading franchising lawyer has told a government inquiry .

Gloria Jeans© Jessica Shapiro Gloria Jeans The government cannot stop small business owners from making stupid decisions, a leading franchising lawyer has told an inquiry into the scandal-plagued $144 billion industry.

HWL Ebsworth special counsel Derek Sutherland said on the opening day of the parliamentary inquiry into the Franchising Code of Conduct that while there had been some "terrible" things happen to franchisees, there was no problem with the current regulatory system.

Mr. Sutherland said the government could not legislate to protect people from their own “stupidity” or conduct when they signed up to become franchisees.

The $64M cost of Qld's rail fail revealed

  The $64M cost of Qld's rail fail revealed Queensland Rail has been hit with $41 million in overtime payments since the start of the so-called 'rail fail' in October 2016.Queensland train drivers have been paid more than $41 million in overtime since the start of cascading timetable failures in Queensland Rail in October 2016, according to figures released by the state opposition.

' Can ' t legislate against stupidity ', franchise inquiry told . The government cannot stop small business owners from making stupid decisions, a leading franchising lawyer has told a government inquiry .

' Can ' t legislate against stupidity ', franchise inquiry told . The government cannot stop small business owners from making stupid decisions, a leading franchising lawyer has told a government inquiry .

“They’re just not taking enough interest at the time when it matters, to really get some advice and make an informed decision," Mr. Sutherland said.

"I’m not saying they're stupid, I’m just saying they’re not taking advantage at the right time, when the decision-making is at the most important.”

The inquiry is probing whether the existing code stands up against allegations of unconscionable and deceptive behaviour by franchise groups.

Industry giants including Domino's, Caltex, 7-Eleven and Retail Food Group have been accused of operating business models that crush franchisees, push many to underpay staff to stay above water and lead others to financial ruin.

Donut King’s days may be numbered, but Crust and Gloria Jean’s are safe

  Donut King’s days may be numbered, but Crust and Gloria Jean’s are safe The dramatic fall in fortunes of Aussie franchise giant Retail Food Group may spell doom for Donut King and Michel’s Patisserie, but Crust Pizza, Pizza Capers and Gloria Jean’s are probably safe. That, at least, is the view of one analyst at IBISWorld, who dampened fears RFG — the controversial owner of these franchise chains — is headed for collapse on the back of a year of massive losses.It’s been a terrible year for RFG, which also owns Brumby’s Bakeries. Negative press, changing consumer behaviour and rising rents have pummelled the company’s bottom line and the share price.

' Can ' t legislate against stupidity ', franchise inquiry told . The government cannot stop small business owners from making stupid decisions, a leading franchising lawyer has told a government

Home › Jesse Ventura Quotes › You Cant Legislate Against Stupidity Well, I tell those people that there was” — Jerry Falwell. Be A Real Father Quotes. “Im from California, but my father, who passed away when I was young, was from Newark.

While franchise agreements say small business owners should get financial and legal advice before entering an agreement, Mr Sutherland said in practice they did not because they did not want to spend the money.

“A lot of them just sign whatever they’re told to sign," he said.

Mr. Sutherland, who said he represented franchisors in his work 80 percent of the time, said there was an imbalance in power and information between franchisors and store owners.

One issue under the microscope is supply contracts where franchisees must buy ingredients from the franchisors.

That has been raised at Retail Food Group, where store owners at chains such as Gloria Jeans have claimed they pay unfairly high prices on coffee beans, which shifts profit margins from their business to head office.

Mr. Sutherland said that existing laws on unconscionable conduct and unfair contract terms were sufficient to police this behaviour.

Reese Witherspoon confirms 'Legally Blonde 3' is being made

  Reese Witherspoon confirms 'Legally Blonde 3' is being made The ruling is in — “Legally Blonde 3” is officially in the works. Reese Witherspoon confirmed that MGM is making a long-rumored third installment to her popular movie franchise by sharing a Twitter video that shows her floating on a pool raft while wearing her character Elle Woods’ classic pink bikini.

Piers cited a number of guin deaths of kids - kids that had guns that were not locked up by the stupid idiot parents. Ben countered ripping Piers by saying that you cannot legislate stupidity and ignorance. How do you legislate bad parents to be good parents?

People are so stupid >sometimes! > Granted. But is the answer another law that seldom gets enforced, simply because there aren' t enough policemen to watch everybody all the time?

However, he said franchisees should be able to collectively negotiate with head office over disputes, which may include over supply agreements, without having to apply for exemption from competition laws.

But it would be "unfair" to allow collective negotiation on supply agreements and other contractual matters as a regular course of events, he said.

The inquiry also heard from Derek Minus, a mediator appointed under the existing Franchising Code, who called for the implementation of an independent arbitrator who could be called in unilaterally and make binding rulings on disputes.

Such a mechanism is included in the Food and Grocery Code on Conduct, which was introduced in response to claims of supermarkets mistreating their suppliers.

Mr. Minus said that his role at the Office of the Franchising Mediation Adviser (OFMA) was largely unknown to franchisees.

Michael Fraser from mediation group Franchise Redress said he and all but one of his clients did not know OFMA existed.

There are over a thousand franchise businesses operating in Australia, and the industry body, The Franchising Council of Australia, has characterised the scandals as a case a few bad apples.

"We would argue that we can’t know the true number of franchisors doing the wrong thing until valid complaints have been investigated," Franchise Redress director Maddison Johnstone told the inquiry.

"If the [Franchising Council] didn’t know about the misconduct of 7-Eleven, Domino’s Pizza, Caltex, and Retail Food Group until they were publicly exposed, then how can they say with such confidence that it’s only a small number of franchisors doing the wrong thing?"

Comment: Pizza wars: paying heavy price for a slice .
When franchisors squeeze franchisees too hard, the consequences can be profound. A Federal Circuit Court case on Thursday outlined the implications when franchisees are struggling. It involved a Pizza Hut franchisee on the Gold Coast who was forced to pay a fine of $216,700 to the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) after admitting he had used sham contracting to underpay a worker, then tried to falsify records to cover it up.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!