Australia Victims critical of Paul de Jersey's intervention in church debate on limiting abuse cases

14:20  14 february  2018
14:20  14 february  2018 Source:   abc.net.au

Vicky Pattison and Paul Burrell to join I'm a Celebrity

  Vicky Pattison and Paul Burrell to join I'm a Celebrity Just when we thought Danny Green was about to shake things up, Vicky Pattison and Paul Burrell are set to join I'm a Celebrity as intruders.And it looks likely to get even more fiery when two intruders are dropped into the camp.

Paul de Jersey advocated for allowing the defence in some cases warning church could lose its insurance. The diocese did not move ahead with scrapping the time limits . Victims and their supporters say Paul de Jersey ’ s position was influential.

Then-chief justice Paul de Jersey warned the Anglican church a push to scrap time limits on victims taking legal action could cost the church its insurance, say victims and their supporters.

What to watch next
  • Police shoot teenager allegedly threatening officers with knife

    Police shoot teenager allegedly threatening officers with knife

    ABC News Logo
    ABC News
    1:50
  • Barnaby is one of the greatest assets to the government and to the Nationals Party: Christensen

    Barnaby is one of the greatest assets to the government and to the Nationals Party: Christensen

    AAP Logo
    AAP
    0:47
  • a man standing next to a car: Tears, hugs as missing autistic teenager found

    Tears, hugs as missing autistic teenager found

    Seven News Logo
    Seven News
    1:27
  • Shock attack on Perth grandfather

    Shock attack on Perth grandfather

    9News.com.au Logo
    9News.com.au
    1:06
  • Fatal crash

    Fatal crash

    tenplay Logo
    tenplay
    2:02
  • a man wearing a suit and tie: Sam for Mayor?

    Sam for Mayor?

    A Current Affair Logo
    A Current Affair
    4:19
  • a close up of a computer: One in five living with ticking cholesterol time bomb

    One in five living with ticking cholesterol time bomb

    Seven News Logo
    Seven News
    1:24
  • EXPLAINER: Barnaby Joyce apologises to family

    EXPLAINER: Barnaby Joyce apologises to family

    AAP Logo
    AAP
    1:57
  • Man charged with murder over shooting of lawyer Ho Le Dinh

    Man charged with murder over shooting of lawyer Ho Le Dinh

    ABC News Logo
    ABC News
    1:13
  • a man holding a fork and knife: Accused drug smuggler released from Balinese prison

    Accused drug smuggler released from Balinese prison

    9News.com.au Logo
    9News.com.au
    1:19
  • a man holding a sign: Where's William?

    Where's William?

    A Current Affair Logo
    A Current Affair
    1:06
  • Formally charged

    Formally charged

    tenplay Logo
    tenplay
    1:35
  • Freezing puppy rescued

    Freezing puppy rescued

    Today Logo
    Today
    0:35
  • a man in a suit and tie: Lord Mayor's expense scandal 'the worst time' of her life

    Lord Mayor's expense scandal 'the worst time' of her life

    Seven News Logo
    Seven News
    1:11
  • RAW: Crane lifts vehicle after woman reverses off cliff

    RAW: Crane lifts vehicle after woman reverses off cliff

    AAP Logo
    AAP
    1:36
  • Pressue mounts on Joyce and Government

    Pressue mounts on Joyce and Government

    ABC News Logo
    ABC News
    2:30
UP NEXT
UP NEXT
Queensland Governor and former chief justice Paul de Jersey and a fellow judge played a key role in thwarting an internal push by Anglican clergy for the church to abandon a contentious legal defence against child sex abuse claims, victims and their supporters say.

Courtney Act says his Big Brother win shows reasoned debate can prevail

  Courtney Act says his Big Brother win shows reasoned debate can prevail Shane Jenek says his victory on Britain's Celebrity Big Brother shows the value in calm and reasoned debate on social and political issues like abortion, same sex marriage and divisions between the gay and trans-gender communities The 35-year old drag queen and reality television veteran, better known as Courtney Act was widely lauded for his explanations about gay and trans issues to fellow contestants which included a trans-woman India and the socially conservative Tory MP Ann Widdicombe who opposes gay marriage and abortion and came runner up.

Cases of child sexual abuse by Catholic priests, nuns and members of religious orders, and subsequent cover-ups, in the 20th and 21st centuries have led to many allegations, investigations

14/02/18 – ABC News – “ Victims critical of Paul de Jersey ’ s intervention in church debate on limiting abuse cases ”. 13/02/18 – ABC News – “Doubts raised about Queensland judges’ links to Anglican Church ”.

Abuse survivors and supporters have criticised the judges' intervention in the 2009 general meeting of the Anglican Brisbane Diocese, which voted down a motion to stop using legal time limits.

The limits forced victims to sue by the age of 21, effectively limiting any institution's potential legal exposure.

The motion, which called on the church to "set an ethical lead in the community by ... not invoking the statute of limitations defence", would have set a nationwide precedent.

But the Queensland Governor, who in 2009 was chief justice and chancellor, or legal advisor, to the diocese, warned the church would lose its insurance.

According to notes of the meeting by an abuse survivor, the chief justice also referred to victims suing because of the church's "deep pockets".

MTV's 'Jersey Shore Family Vacation' Gets a Premiere Date -- See the First Look!

  MTV's 'Jersey Shore Family Vacation' Gets a Premiere Date -- See the First Look! ET has your first look at the revival series, which returns to the network on Thursday, April 5.And this time, the crew is taking over Miami, Florida! In a sneak peek clip from the reboot, the reality stars hug, chug and announce to the city, "We're your new neighbors!!!"

Catholic sex abuse cases in the United States are a series of lawsuits, criminal prosecutions, and scandals over sexual abuse by Roman Catholic clergy.

It comes after legal experts raised doubts about the appropriateness of judges' roles as legal advisors to the church.

This included a perceived conflict of interest for Justice de Jersey over his role in a 1998 legal review of time limits, including in child sex abuse cases.

'The insurer's call'

The chief justice in 2009 supported an amendment moved by deputy chancellor and fellow Supreme Court Justice, Debra Mullins, which tempered the motion on time limits.

It asked the diocese instead to negotiate with insurers to "establish a protocol for dealing with claims by victims of child sex abuse when the diocese considers it appropriate not to invoke the time limitation defence".

The proviso was "without losing indemnity from our insurers".

The diocese had for several years lobbied the Queensland Government to scrap the time limits.

But it was not until 2016, after the royal commission called for the urgent scrapping of a "great injustice", that time limits were abolished by the State Government.

U.S. Olympic swimmer accuses ex-coach of sexual abuse when she was 16

  U.S. Olympic swimmer accuses ex-coach of sexual abuse when she was 16 By Jonathan Allen

The Church teaches that the Papal infallibility on limited theological matters does not signify that the Pope was a man specially exempt from liability to sin. Victims of such abuse filed lawsuits against a number of dioceses, resulting in multi-million dollar settlements in some cases .

Paul McGennis abused M Collins when she was in Our Lady' s Hospital for Sick Children in 1961, when she was 13. "Cardinal Sean Brady: McGuinness and Gilmore critical ". BBC. Retrieved 2014-01-02. Debate over causes. Government responses. Ferns Report. Roman Catholic Church sex abuse cases in Ireland.

According to the victim's 2009 notes, Justice de Jersey told the meeting that sometimes the church might want to use the time limit defence, for example if it was concerned a fair trial could not be had because of the lapse of time, but it was "the insurer's call".

The notes state he argued if the church walked away from that, it was effectively "condemning itself" to carrying the entire financial burden of resolving victims' claims.

In the notes, Peter Shayler-Webb, the priest who put the motion to stop using time limits, took exception to the chief justice's comment.

"I find it rather strange that the chancellor should use the words, 'We condemn ourselves to be financially liable' ... for things that we have done," he said.

"We are taking accountability and responsibility for what has happened to people in our care."

Victims 'insulted'

Victims and their supporters say the judges' intervention sent a troubling message to abuse survivors.

One victim, who had a live case in which the church conceded the abuse but invoked the lime limit, said he was "insulted" when he heard the "deep pockets" comment.

YouTube details how it will punish creators for ‘harming’ the community

  YouTube details how it will punish creators for ‘harming’ the community YouTube this afternoon detailed new policy changes going into effect after the latest controversy featuring YouTube creator Logan Paul, who had <g class="gr_ gr_10 gr-alert gr_gramm gr_inline_cards gr_run_anim Grammar multiReplace" data-gr-id="10" id="10">advertising</g> temporarily suspended on his account today over videos featuring the abuse of a dead animal.&nbsp;The changes are straightforward: YouTube says it reserves the right to strip a channel of its ability to serve ads and its access to premium monetization programs like Google Preferred and its YouTube Partner Program, as well as the right to cease recommending a channel’s videos across its network, if that c

This page documents Catholic Church sex abuse cases by country. The Catholic sexual abuse scandal in Europe has been documented by cases in several dioceses in European nations.

This interview was the first time Hlavka spoke publicly about the abuse he suffered, having initially filed his case against the church as “John Doe 117”. But without these window laws, childhood sex abuse victims are held to state statute of limitations law that have in many cases long passed.

"Victims do not sue the diocese because they have 'deep pockets'," the man, who asked not to be named, said.

"Victims sue the diocese because of the overwhelming evidence that the diocese knew about the abuse and knew about the offenders yet did nothing to stop the abuse nor prevent further abuse."

Psychiatrist and abuse trauma expert Warwick Middleton said he had spoken to another victim who was at the meeting and felt that opinions were being expressed "about the potential for people to get on the gravy train and bleed the church dry".

"One's got to be very, very careful for the words that are said in public forums in respect to the victims who are also in the forum listening to this, saying, 'We've been abused by this church and now we're hearing the considered view of the church coming down to a question of economics'," he said.

Andrew Bode, a victims advocate and Griffith university academic who spoke out against the judges' "economic" argument, said it was "not a moral approach".

But Dr Bode said he felt the judges managed to "stifle the debate" and decisively swing the vote "by virtue of their position".

"Here we have the chief justice or the chancellor, and the deputy chancellor, in great positions of power, within that synod, and obviously speaking to support something I guess that they believed was quite correct," he told the ABC.

"And yet other people within the floor of the synod may have disagreed but were perhaps intimidated by their position.

"The church had a wonderful opportunity to set an ethical lead and I think that would have been, in my belief, a very wise thing.

"But on the other hand to stifle it, to me was not the right thing to do."

Judge defends position

Justice Mullins said she did not agree that "my intervention ... carried weight because of my 'public stature' as a Supreme Court judge".

"My views have not always prevailed in debates at the Synod, which comprises approximately 400 lay people and clergy," she told the ABC.

Justice Mullins said she moved the amendment "because, in 2009, my belief was that the diocese should not abandon reliance on the limitations defence, if that would deprive the diocese of the benefit of indemnity from its insurers".

"You should note that for a number of years before that synod, the diocese had been calling on the Queensland state government to abolish time limitations in child sexual abuse cases," she said.

Governor Paul de Jersey declined to comment.

Telstra apologises for billing identity fraud victims .
Since 9NEWS revealed the story of Andrew Dwight and his battle with Telstra over 10 mobile phones that were added to his account without his knowledge, more claims of identity theft at the telco have surfaced. Graeme Robinson is a pensioner from the Sydney suburb of Colyton. His mobile phone bill is usually well under $200, so when he received one for more than $1,100 he went to Telstra and the police straight away.Over the next few months, the bill increased even further to $2,702 as more new iPhones were added to the account without his knowledge.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!